Best Pie Plates Reviewed and Compared

Ovenware which enables us to achieve delicious, perfectly cooked food is always a great addition to our kitchen particularly when it comes with the added benefit of being especially flexible, making the entire process extra easy. And that is what makes pie plates a firm favorite in kitchens all over the world.

If you are considering making a purchase for your own home, you will love our list of the 10 best pie plates which will provide you with an idea of what will work best for you.

Our Top 3 Picks

Pyrex 2-Pack Easy Grab Glass Pie Plate
  • Pyrex 2-Pack Easy Grab Glass Pie Plate
  • 5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Versatility
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review
Baker’s Advantage Ceramic Deep Pie
  • Baker’s Advantage Ceramic Deep Pie
  • 4.6 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Ideal material
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review
Rose Levy Beranbaum’s Perfect Pie Plate
  • Rose Levy Beranbaum’s Perfect Pie Plate
  • 4.2 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Ideal cookware
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review

10 Best Pie Plates

 

1. Pyrex

Read Reviews & Buy on
Every homeowner dreams of finding that pie dish that will make everything so much more convenient in the kitchen while cooking our food to perfection. Thankfully the kitchenware manufacturer Pyrex which is renowned for providing both professional and amateur cooks with items which have been carefully designed to bring out the best in their dishes can always be relied on. Below we take a look at what makes its 2-Pack Easy Grab Glass Pie Plate the perfect solution to everyone’s dream.
Expand to see more
A combination of versatility and functionality

The 2-Pack Easy Grab Glass Pie Plate can be used in your oven, microwave, fridge, freezer and dishwasher. Thanks to the clear glass used in its manufacture, you will also be able to closely monitor the process of your pie, cakes or casseroles baking, further minimizing the risk of any mishaps occurring.

Features and Specifications

Manufacturer: Pyrex
Product Dimensions: 11.2 x 11.2 x 2.1 inches
Weight: 2.2 pounds
Color: glass
Category: Kitchenware

Price/Value

These Pyrex dishes are pretty cheap and are a great bargain. The fact that they have also been manufactured by the leading kitchenware producer which has become a household name also attests to their quality.

Decision

If you want a pair of dishes which will ensure your layered cakes, pies or casseroles turn out just right, then you will love these dishes. The fact that they are made of glass also makes them a great choice since they distribute heat evenly and slowly resulting in amazing food.
Pros
  • Non porous glass which is warp, stain and odor resistant.
  • Food-safe silicone surface.
  • Easy to wash.
  • Microwave, oven, fridge, freezer and dishwasher safe.
Cons
  • These pie dishes are heavy making it necessary to handle them with care.

2. Baker’s Advantage

Read Reviews & Buy on
When it comes to the choice of material for getting the best results for your pies and quiches the response always comes down to that material which is not only capable of distributing heat evenly but one which is also robust and durable. We have provided an overview of the Baker’s Advantage Ceramic Deep Pie Dish which meets all these qualities and more below.
Expand to see more
The ideal material for baking

Thanks to its ability to distribute heat evenly, and even more efficiently than glass, the Baker’s Advantage Ceramic Deep Pie Dish is the ideal item for ovenware. Its low porosity also makes it particularly resistant to staining and certainly makes it perfect for all your baking needs.

Features and Specifications

Manufacturer: Baker’s Advantage
Product Dimensions: 10.4 x 10.4 x 2.4 inches
Weight: 3 pounds
Color: Red
Category: Kitchenware

Price/Value

The Baker’s Advantage Ceramic Deep Pie Dish is moderately priced making it especially suitable for baking all your favorites. Its pleasant light design and especially durable nature make it worth considering as a possible addition to your ovenware collection.

Decision

When it comes to selecting pie plates, ceramic is always the best option, even compared to glass. That is because it is capable of withstanding sudden temperature changes and of baking its contents really efficiently. These qualities make the Baker’s Advantage Ceramic Deep Pie Dish an excellent choice.
Pros
  • Professional quality stoneware.
  • Low porosity.
Cons
  • Must be washed by hand.

3. Rose Levy

Read Reviews & Buy on
If you enjoy a pie plate which not only makes baking beautifully decorated pies possible for you but is also versatile enough to be used as a serving dish, you will love Rose Levy Beranbaum’s Perfect Pie Plate. Details on what makes it worth adding to your kitchenware collection can be viewed below.
Expand to see more
The ideal cookware item for any kitchen

Investing in kitchenware which is especially versatile is always a great idea. This pie plate not only comes with deep fluted edges, which will result in decorative pie crusts but can also be used a serving dish for other foods. It is also resistant to staining, odors and cracking and is likely to become a treasured part of your kitchenware collection as a result.

Features and Specifications

Manufacturer: HIC Harold Import Co.
Product Dimensions: 9 x 9 x 1.9 inches
Weight: 2.3 pounds
Color: Blue
Category: Kitchenware

Price/Value

The Rose Levy Beranbaum’s Perfect Pie Plate is averagely priced and fully suitable for the modern kitchen. As a result, it is worth purchasing if you would like a robust pie plate which can be adapted to suit other purposes.

Decision

If your aim is buying a pie plate which would result in perfectly baked pies with a decorative crust in addition to being exceptionally robust and versatile in your kitchen, this pie plate from ‘the most meticulous cook who ever lived’ will make a great addition to your kitchen. Particularly since it comes at a really reasonable price and is easy to clean due to being dishwasher safe.
Pros
  • Deep fluted edges for baking pies with decorative crusts
  • 4 cup capacity.
  • Dishwasher safe.
Cons
  • May be too shallow for certain pies.

4. The Pioneer Woman

Read Reviews & Buy on
Presentation is everything. Especially when it comes to food. Hence no one can really go wrong with a really beautifully decorated pie plate which is not only durable but would also make its contents look simply amazing. Just like the Pioneer Woman 9 Inch Stoneware Pie Dish which has been described in detail below.
Expand to see more
An excellent choice for baking and serving

The Pioneer Woman 9 Inch Stoneware Pie Dish comes with a really beautiful floral pattern which makes it stand out from other similar items,

In addition to being highly decorative, it is also microwave and dishwasher safe and capable of withstanding temperatures of up to 450 degrees in your oven. These qualities mean it will make your baking a breeze and also add a decorative touch to your table.

Features and Specifications

Manufacturer: HIC Harold Import Co.
Product Dimensions: 11.2 x 11.1 x 3.7 inches
Weight: 2.6 pounds
Color: White & green
Category: Kitchenware

Price/Value

This item is more expensive than basic pie plates. However it does a lot more than them and is also better looking too. If you want a pie plate which is incredibly versatile and which also comes with decorative detail, getting it might be a good idea.

Decision

If you really like prettily decorated ovenware which also doubles as tableware, you will like the Pioneer Woman 9 Inch Stoneware Pie Dish. Particularly since it will make things a lot easier in the kitchen for you due to its suitability for microwave, oven and dishwasher use.

Pros
  • Oven safe to 450 degrees.
  • Microwave safe.
  • Dishwasher safe.
  • Unique floral design.
Cons
  • Slightly more costly than similar items.

5. Anchor Hocking

Read Reviews & Buy on
Homeowners and chefs everywhere all agree that white tableware has a way of making its contents look especially appetizing. Especially when they are of exceptional quality. If you are interested in adding that extra special touch they bring to your table, the Anchor Hocking Pie Plate may be just what you need. Find out more about it below.
Expand to see more
High quality multipurpose kitchenware

The Anchor Hocking Pie Plate is one pie plate which is especially robust and versatile. In addition to being suitable for baking at high temperatures, it is also suitable for serving and will add a lovely touch to your dining table. What’s more it can also be used for serving other dishes too and is capable of making all its contents look equally amazing.

Features and Specifications

Manufacturer: Anchor Hocking
Product Dimensions: 11 x 2.8 x 11 inches
Weight: 2.7pounds
Color: White
Category: Kitchenware

Price/Value

The Anchor Hocking Pie Plate is slightly more expensive than other similar pie plates. However it makes up for this with its versatility in your kitchen and its elegant design which will add a special touch to the ambience of your dining room when used to serve food.

Decision

If you believe in making your dishes look extra delicious and in creating an atmosphere that will make your guests feel as though they are being treated to fine dining, getting this pie plate is a great idea. The fact that it is quite robust means it is likely to add its unique elegance to your kitchen and dining room for a long time.
Pros
  • High quality ceramic.
  • Even heat distribution for improved results.
  • Suitable for serving a range of other dishes.
Cons
  • Unsuitable for dishwasher use.

6. OvenStuff

Read Reviews & Buy on
When it comes to cookware which makes food preparation extra convenient, nonstick items come at the top of the list since they make it really easy to remove their contents without the risk of any major mishaps. The OvenStuff Nonstick Pie Pan 2 Piece Set is one example of such amazing kitchenware and its key details can be examined in detail below.
Expand to see more
Duraglide nonstick finish

Struggling to remove a cake or pie which is meant to be served to guests in perfect condition can be quite stressful particularly since they could end up getting fragmented, and ruining hours of preparing ingredients and loads of hard work. Thankfully, that will never be the case with the OvenStuff Nonstick Pie Pan 2 Piece Set due to its Duraglide nonstick finish which makes it easy to remove its contents effortlessly and will ensure your pies and cakes are served in perfect form.

Features and Specifications

Manufacturer: G & S Metal Products Company
Product Dimensions: 9 x 1.8 x 9 inches
Weight: 1pound
Color: Gray
Category: Kitchenware

Price/Value

These pie plates which are perfectly suitable for the modern kitchen also come with the added benefit of being one of the cheapest available making them a great bargain as a result.

Decision

The OvenStuff Nonstick Pie Pan 2 Piece Set ticks all the right boxes in terms of being really convenient to use. The fact that you can be certain of releasing your cakes and pies from them in one piece due to their nonstick finish is also an added bonus. And once their price is taken into consideration, they certainly become worth adding to your ovenware collection, even though they come with the slight drawback of being unsuitable for serving purposes.
Pros
  • Duraglide nonstick finish.
  • Heavyweight steel construction for even heat distribution.
  • Suitability for dishwasher use.
Cons
  • Susceptible to scratching.
  • Unsuitable for serving purposes.

7. Corelle

Read Reviews & Buy on
Certain products from certain manufacturers always come with a guarantee of quality. Especially since they meet all your needs and make your cakes and quiches appear extremely tempting. The Corelle Livingware 9-Inch Deep Dish Pie Plate, Winter Frost White by the kitchen and tableware manufacturer Corelle is one such example and we have provided information on what makes it stand out in comparison to other pie plates below.
Expand to see more
Impressive durability and functionality

Unlike a number of more traditionally designed pie plates the Corelle Livingware 9-Inch Deep Dish Pie Plate can also be used in your dishwasher and microwave in addition to being suitable for use in your oven.

Due to being winter frost white it is also suitable for serving and will complement other dishes thanks to its neutral color. What’s more it is also quite durable and is resistant to chipping and breaking ensuring it will maintain its charm for longer.

Features and Specifications

Manufacturer: Corelle
Product Dimensions: 10.2 x 10.2 x 1.5 inches
Weight: 13.6 ounces
Color: White
Category: Kitchenware

Price/Value

The Corelle Livingware 9-Inch Deep Dish Pie Plate is a really great bargain since it is one of the cheapest pie plates available. Its versatility, durability and ease of storage and handling make it a great purchase.

Decision

While more traditional glass and ceramic pie plates are renowned for providing the best results, the Corelle Livingware 9-Inch Deep Dish Pie Plate does stand out in terms of its versatility, weightlessness and durability. Its price and suitability for serving food are also added bonuses which make it worth purchasing.
Pros
  • Dishwasher, microwave and oven safe.
  • Resistant to chipping and breaking.
  • Can be stacked for easy storage.
Cons
  • Heat distribution properties unspecified.

8. Glass Bakeware

8. Glass Bakeware See more images here[]
Read Reviews & Buy on[]
Nowadays pie plate manufacturers are deviating from more traditional models to create items which are perfectly suitable for the modern kitchen in all respects while also retaining their traditional features that made them such a great choice in the first place. The Glass Bakeware Pie Plate [4-Pack] is an example of one of these pie plates and we have provided details of what makes it worth considering below.
Expand to see more
Heavy duty glass for excellent performance

The suitability of glass ovenware for product excellent baking results is well documented. In addition, these dishes also come with the added bonus of being suitable for microwave, fridge, freeze and dishwasher use. They are also stain and odor resistant meaning that they equally suitable for frequent use.

Features and Specifications

Manufacturer: Garden plus Home
Product Dimensions: 9 x 1.5 x 9 inches
Weight: 3 pounds
Color: Glass
Category: Kitchenware

Price/Value

The Glass Bakeware Pie Plate [4-Pack] represents great value for money since it costs less than a number of individual pie plates and actually comes as a set of 4. The fact that it is also a great deal more flexible in terms of use than the majority of pie plates available make it an excellent bargain which should be taken advantage of.

Decision

If you would like to bake and serve your food in style, for a fraction of the price, while enjoying a great experience, purchasing this set of pie plates is a great idea. Particularly since it ticks all the right boxes in terms of what great ovenware and table ware ought to bring to your table.
Pros
  • Easy to store due to being stackable.
  • Microwave, freezer, dishwasher, fridge safe.
  • Non porous and stain and odor resistant as a result.
Cons
  • Unsuitable for temperatures exceeding 500 degrees.

9. Emile Henry

Read Reviews & Buy on
When it comes to getting the ovenware that will bake your pies, quiches and cakes just the way you like them, one of the best things to do is trust the experts. Like Emile Henry which has catered to baking professionals and enthusiasts since 1850. We have provided details on its Emile Henry Made in France 9 Inch Pie Dish below.
Expand to see more
Superior heat retention

The Emile Henry Made in France 9 Inch Pie Dish has been made from Burgundy clay which is not only completely natural but also highly efficient in terms of heat retention and heat diffusion and will keep your food warmer for longer once it has been removed from the oven.



Temperature resistant

This pie plate is suitable for use in the oven for up to 520 degrees F and can also be used in the oven, broiler and microwave. It is also possible to place it right in the oven or table right from the freezer or fridge making your food preparation really convenient as a result.

Features and Specifications

Manufacturer: Emile Henry
Product Dimensions: 10.2 x 10.2 x 2.2 inches
Weight: 14.4 ounces
Color: Brown
Category: Kitchenware

Price/Value

In terms of price, this pie plate is more expensive than all the others which have been covered in this list. That is not surprising since it is one of the most impressive. If you want a pie plate which will be highly efficient and durable, this item is really worth purchasing.

Decision

Temperature resistant, flexible and robust, this pie plate brought to you by the French manufacturer Emile Henry is one of the best examples of what the perfect pie plate is meant to be. And you can be sure that you will enjoy baking your favorite cakes, quiches and pies with it.


Pros
  • Temperature resistant.
  • Impressive resistance to temperature.
  • Excellent heat retention.
  • Suitable for dishwasher use.
Cons
  • More expensive than other brands.

10. Camp Chef

Read Reviews & Buy on
Glass ceramic and aluminum pie plates are some of the more popular options preferred by chefs and cooking amateurs all over the world. However there is another pie plate which comes with its own set of benefits and can provide you with a whole new experience. The cast iron pie plate. If you have ever wondered if purchasing one is a good idea, you can find out more about them thanks to the preview provided below of the Camp Chef True Seasoned Cast Iron Pie Pan.


Expand to see more
A new flexible approach to cooking

The Camp Chef True Seasoned Cast Iron Pie Pan is capable of withstanding oven temperatures of up to 500 degrees in the oven. It is also great for preparing recipes which require ingredients which need to be seared on a cooker before being placed in the oven or vice versa and will provide you with great crusts for your pies and rolls.

Features and Specifications

Manufacturer: Emile Henry
Product Dimensions: 11 x 3 x 11 inches
Weight: 5 pounds
Color: Black
Category: Kitchenware

Price/Value

The Camp Chef True Seasoned Cast Iron Pie Pan represents the opportunity for a whole new different experience for anyone who loves creating dishes that require using their stove hob and oven for the same recipe. Best of all it is really cheap and will make a great addition to any cooking enthusiast’s kitchenware collection.

Decision

Suitable for your stove hob and oven, capable of providing you with the best pastries and breads, you have ever had, the Camp Chef True Seasoned Cast Iron Pie Pan certainly comes with an impressive range of qualities. It even comes preseasoned so you can use it right away. Its price is really great too. All these qualities mean it is worth adding to your collection if you enjoy kitchenware that provides you with flexibility when cooking


Pros

 

  • Pre-seasoned by the manufacturer.
  • Decorative molded cast iron handles provided for added safety.
  • Capable of withstanding high temperatures.

 

Cons
  • Must be seasoned regularly to prevent rusting.
  • Unsuitable for dishwasher use.

FAQs

Q: How expensive are pie plates?

Pie plates are some of the most affordable kitchenware and do not cost much on average at all. Even the more expensive ones are likely to be generally affordable too.

Q: What is the best material to choose for a pie plate?

There are several options to choose from and each comes with their own specific advantages.

For example glass and ceramic are preferred for their even distribution of heat which ensures the contents of the dish are cooked to perfection.

Cast iron on the other hand can be used on both stove hobs and in the oven and is capable of withstanding really high temperatures.

Q: What qualities should I look out for in a pie plate?

Basic qualities should include suitability for oven, microwave and dishwasher use as well as the ability to withstand high temperatures. However it is worth noting that cast iron pans need to be washed by hand and may not be suitable for dishwasher use.

Additional features which are also great are suitability for freezer, refrigerator use and a resistance to chipping and scratching.