Skip to Content

Best Cookie Sheets Reviewed

Best Cookie Sheets Reviewed

Not happy with the type of cookie sheets you used up until now? We rated the 10 best cookie sheets available in 2017 and reviewed each in detail!

We know that you care about the taste and deliciousness of the made at home cookies. We know that baking your own cookies is a demonstration of devotion towards yourself and the family members in terms of healthy and tasty eating. That is why, are consider ourselves responsible to support you in the decision-making process, so you will choose the best one.

Usually, when we are about to bake our own cookies, we are highly focused in the recipe ingredients and we do not pay high attention to the cookies sheet.

But, our experts say that the proper cookie sheet is the next step towards success whenever you are about to bake something. Cookie sheets might seem to be a simple appliance, but it is not.

Thus, you are invited to check few facts and information on the cookies sheets and then consult our experts buying guide. First product on this best cookie sheets list is your best one.

There are 3 main types of cookie sheets:

  • Insulated Cookie Sheets
  • Aluminum
  • Black Steel

Insulated Cookie Sheets

These type of cookie sheets are non- stick. They are usually considered to be faster in terms of baking and overprotective in terms of overbaking.

They can be easily cleaned up since they do not stick the baked food. Users should be careful not to damage the surface during the cleaning up process.

As far as color is concerned, the lighter the color of the cookie sheet, the brighter the color of the cooked cookies. The darker the color of the cookie sheet, the darker the color of the cooked cookies.


This type of cookie sheets are usually well known in regards to even baking because of aluminum material properties in terms of heat distribution.

They are usually being provided in different shapes since aluminum material allows this.

One of the peculiarities aluminum cookies sheets have is that when baking acidic cookies they can negatively interact with the aluminum coat and leave a metallic flavor at the end.

Black Steel

Black steel cookie sheets are a good heat transmitter thus the cookies would get properly cooked and baked at the end. The black steel cookie sheets are heavy in weight.

In order for them to provide the best result, it is advisable to oil before baking the cookies.

If you are feeling like lost amidst huge amounts of different cookie sheets, and you consider yourself not able to select the best one meeting your needs, than we strongly suggest you to consult what our best professionals have already reviewed and selected in this top 10 list.

Our professional experts are aware on common consumer demands and expectations, thus you can trust their experience and judgment in regards to the selection of the best sheets.

10 Best Cookie Sheets


[guide_post id=”2684″][/guide_post][srp_anchshortcode id=”2693″][/srp_anchshortcode] [guide_post id=”2685″][/guide_post][srp_anchshortcode id=”2694″][/srp_anchshortcode] [guide_post id=”2686″][/guide_post][srp_anchshortcode id=”2695″][/srp_anchshortcode] [guide_post id=”2687″][/guide_post] [guide_post id=”2688″][/guide_post] [guide_post id=”2689″][/guide_post] [guide_post id=”2683″][/guide_post] [guide_post id=”2690″][/guide_post] [guide_post id=”2691″][/guide_post] [guide_post id=”2692″][/guide_post]

General considerations …

Whenever considering to buy a cookie sheet for the first time, or even add a new one to your existing collection, you need to know the purpose why you are buying it.

As our experts suggest, cookie sheets are being provided in the market in different types, material and shape. Some of them are best for lighter cookies, some others are best for darker ones. It is strongly advisable to buy tailored cookie sheets for any type of purpose.

In order to understand the best choice, you need to have a look on the most frequent recipes you use.

Whenever choosing the best cookie sheet, keep in consideration temperature as well. Different type of cookie sheets stand different heat temperatures.

Our experts have been testing different types of cookie sheets, having in mind different type of users in regards to types of recipes and tastes.

Thus, the proposed and reviewed best cookie sheets selected are coming as a proposition for all sorts of end users/ consumers.

Each of you can find the appropriate solution for your demands amidst these 10 different types.

Do you like this recipe or recipe list?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating / 5. Vote count:

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.