Best Cookie Sheets Reviewed

Not happy with the type of cookie sheets you used up until now? We rated the 10 best cookie sheets available in 2017 and reviewed each in detail!

We know that you care about the taste and deliciousness of the made at home cookies. We know that baking your own cookies is a demonstration of devotion towards yourself and the family members in terms of healthy and tasty eating. That is why, are consider ourselves responsible to support you in the decision-making process, so you will choose the best one.

Usually, when we are about to bake our own cookies, we are highly focused in the recipe ingredients and we do not pay high attention to the cookies sheet. But, our experts say that the proper cookie sheet is the next step towards success whenever you are about to bake something. Cookie sheets might seem to be a simple appliance, but it is not. Thus, you are invited to check few facts and information on the cookies sheets and then consult our experts buying guide. First product on this best cookie sheets list is your best one.

There are 3 main types of cookie sheets:

  • Insulated Cookie Sheets
  • Aluminum
  • Black Steel

Insulated Cookie Sheets

These type of cookie sheets are non- stick. They are usually considered to be faster in terms of baking and overprotective in terms of overbaking.

They can be easily cleaned up since they do not stick the baked food. Users should be careful not to damage the surface during the cleaning up process.

As far as color is concerned, the lighter the color of the cookie sheet, the brighter the color of the cooked cookies. The darker the color of the cookie sheet, the darker the color of the cooked cookies.

Aluminum

This type of cookie sheets are usually well known in regards to even baking because of aluminum material properties in terms of heat distribution.

They are usually being provided in different shapes since aluminum material allows this.

One of the peculiarities aluminum cookies sheets have is that when baking acidic cookies they can negatively interact with the aluminum coat and leave a metallic flavor at the end.

Black Steel

Black steel cookie sheets are a good heat transmitter thus the cookies would get properly cooked and baked at the end. The black steel cookie sheets are heavy in weight.

In order for them to provide the best result, it is advisable to oil before baking the cookies.

If you are feeling like lost amidst huge amounts of different cookie sheets, and you consider yourself not able to select the best one meeting your needs, than we strongly suggest you to consult what our best professionals have already reviewed and selected in this top 10 cookie sheets review.

Our professional experts are aware on common consumer demands and expectations, thus you can trust their experience and judgment in regards to the selection of the best cookie sheets.

Our Top 3 Picks

Nordic Ware Sheet
  • Nordic Ware Sheet
  • 5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Easy Clean Up
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review
Good Cook Set
  • Good Cook Set
  • 4.6 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Updated design
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review
AirBake Sheet Set
  • AirBake Sheet Set
  • 4.2 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Modern
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review

10 Best Cookie Sheets

 

1. Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Sheet

Read Reviews & Buy on
The Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker’s half sheet is coming as an attractive and practical solution to all those individuals who are cookies fans. The cookie sheet aluminum surface allows you to achieve a nice smooth coat of cookies that do not stick.

Expand to see more
Easy Clean Up

You do not need to bother on how to clean the cookie sheet anymore. The Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker’s half sheet material is completely non- stick one, thus it can be easily cleaned with water.
Features and Specifications

Pan measures 15. 25 in. x 10. 25 in. x 0. 75 in
Rack measures 14 in. x 10 in

Price/ Value

The price that this cookie sheet is being provided by the vendors is really attractive and justifiable considering the performance of the product.

Decision Time

If you are looking for a good performing cookie sheet that will not stick your cookies, or even other foods cooked in it, than you are offered this specific cookie sheet.
Pros
  • Non-stick material
  • Minimalistic gorgeous design
  • Easy to clean and maintain
Cons
  • Not recommended to use over 400 degrees

2. Good Cook Non-Stick Cookie Sheet

Read Reviews & Buy on
The product we are offering is a set of 3 rectangular cookie sheets. The sheets are made of nonstick material which grants you the opportunity of enjoying a smooth coat and regular shape. The set sheets are coming in 3 different sizes that can be used in different situations: small, medium and large.

Expand to see more
Lifetime Exchange Guarantee

The vendors are providing the Good Cook Set of 3 Non- Stick Cookie Sheet with a lifetime exchange guarantee. This does imply that the vendors are sure on the product reliability, but yet are giving their customers the possibility to satisfy their needs as years pass by.

Updated design 2015

The design of the product has been updated during 2015 in order for the product to provide an increased durability.

Features and Specifications

Product Dimensions: 19. 6 x 12. 6 x 6. 8 inches
Item Weight: 3. 3 pounds
Color: Multicolor
Material: Stainless Steel

Price/ Value

The set of cookie sheets is being provided at a very interesting and affordable price.

Decision Time

To those individuals who are cookie addicted and are always looking for quantities despite quality, the Good Cook Set of 3 Non- Stick Cookie Sheet would be the perfect suggestion. Non- stick sheets that are being sold in a set of 3 different sizes.
Pros
  • Non- Stick Cookie Sheet
  • Simplistic design
  • Easy to clean
  • Quality product
Cons
  • It may "wrap" above 400 in the oven

3. AirBake Natural Cookie Sheet

Read Reviews & Buy on
The AirBake Natural 2 Pack Cookie Sheet Set is coming with air insulation solution. This type of technology applied prevents top sheet from overheating. In return, this results into burning phenomena avoidance.

Expand to see more
Micro-Dome technology

This technology makes possible to decrease the bake time by at least 15- percent. It means that the device is energy efficient at the same time.

Features and Specifications

Product Dimensions :16 x 14 x 2 inches
Item Weight: 1. 8 pounds
Material Type: Aluminum
Color: Silver

Price/ Value

Considering the highly technological feasibility of this set, it is still being found in the market with a great affordable price.

Decision Time

If you will decide to make the AirBake Natural 2 Pack Cookie Sheet Set part of your cooking tools, our experts assure you will be adding a wonderful instrument that will satisfy your cookies taste.
Pros
  • Modern set of cookie sheets
  • Fits to all cooking purposes thanks to the materials and technology used to built them
  • Quality products
Cons
  • May lose its color in the dishwasher

4. Rachael Ray Oven Lovin’ Cookie Sheet

Read Reviews & Buy on
The Rachel Ray Oven Lovin’ Non- Stick Crispy Cookie baking sheet is a very interesting product that has been considered convenient to a number of users. Its convenience lays in the fact that it can be used not only to bake cookies, but also many other foods (desserts or other dishes).

Expand to see more
Easy Silicone Grips

The orange colored grips handles provide a colorful touch to this product and a feasible grasp. The silicon used to produce the handles is oven safe up to 450°F.

Features and Specifications

Product Dimensions: 17 x 11 x 1. 5 inches
Outer dimensions are: 20. 25 x 12. 5 x 1. 75
Item Weight: 2 pounds
Material Type: Anodized Steel
Color: Orange

Price/ Value

The price is superb. Once you will be looking for similar products in the market, you will come to same conclusion when considering the benefits that this product offers.

Decision Time

This product can be suitable for large families and individual purposes at the same time. It provides excellent baking of your cookies and other foods and can be easily cleaned after usage.
Pros
  • Durable product
  • Long- lasting nonstick coat  
  • Easy to clean
Cons
  • May not fit everyone's oven

5. Baker’s Secret Essentials

Read Reviews & Buy on
Baker’s Secret Bakeware is a 2 piece small cookie sheet set. It is made of non- stick material which grants the users the possibility to enjoy their cookies without risking sticking or burning.
Expand to see more
Hard- Anodized Aluminum even heat distribution

Thanks to the hard- anodized aluminum used to produce the Baker’s Secret Bakeware set of cookie sheets, heat is evenly distributed so you can achieve properly balanced cooked cookies or other food.

Features and Specifications

Color: grey
Item Dimensions: 10. 08 x 14. 98 x 0. 93 in
Material Type: Hard- Anodized Aluminum
Item Weight: 1. 6 pounds

Price/ Value

The set is being sold at a very normal price in the market.

Decision Time

We would suggest this set of cookie sheets to all those individuals who are looking for taste, cleaning easiness and a good price at the same time.
Pros
  • Non-stick
  • Easy to clean
  • Resilient 
Cons
  • While cooking the surface may become uneven

6. Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware

Read Reviews & Buy on
The Calphalon Non- Stick Bakeware, Cookie Sheet, does not allow heat to concentrate on a hot spot, instead it makes possible heat even distribution. It is made of a non- stick coat that products the smooth cookie coat. The inner part of each of the pieces is made of interlocking non- stick layers that provide a great release.

Expand to see more
Dishwasher-safe

The great news is that this cookie sheet, although of interlocking technology, can be perfectly and safely washed in a dishwasher.

Interlocking Nonstick Layers Release Easily

The Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Large Baking Sheet is coming with interlocking nonstick layers. These layers are ensuring non- sticky surface/ coat food.

Features and Specifications

Product Dimensions : 17. 5 x 14 x 0. 6 inches
Item Weight: 1. 6 pounds
Color: Silver
Material Type: Steel

Price/ Value

Considering the technology and material used for this product, the price it is being offered is considered to be satisfying.

Decision Time

If you are addicted to technology and cookies deliciousness, this product seems to be a good combination of these two elements.
Pros
  • Practical
  • Attractive minimalistic design.
  • Can be used for different types of cooking/ baking purposes
Cons
  • Heavy

7. Farberware Insulated Nonstick Bakeware

Read Reviews & Buy on
The Faberware Jumbo Cookie Sheet is an insulated cookie pan that is conceptualized with a double pan layers enclosing an air pocket. This method empowers proper heat distribution avoiding chances of hot spots. The insulation method enables the product to bake even on its edges.

Expand to see more
Heavy-duty carbon steel construction

The heavy-duty carbon steel construction enables the product to resist warping even on temperatures around 450 degrees Fahrenheit.

Features and Specifications

Color: Gray
Item Dimensions: 0. 5 x 15. 5 x 20 in
Item Weight: 3 pounds
Material Type: Carbon Steel

Price/ Value

The price can be deliberately considered as a great one. The product benefits outstand the price it is being offered in the market.

Decision Time

If you are looking for an enjoyable experience and are devoted to having delicious tasteful cookies, this is considered to be the Jumbo Cookie Sheet tailored for your needs.
Pros
  • Amazing quality
  • Sturdy
  • Resilient
  • Easy to clean
Cons
  • Heavy

8. Art and Cook Non-Stick Cookie Sheet

Read Reviews & Buy on
The Art and Cook set of 3 Pieces of Non- Stick 2 sheets is another product that did satisfy our experts’ expectations during their testing procedures. Thanks to the highly durable material used for the production of this set, the pan is resistant to heat up to 400 Degrees.

Expand to see more
Quilted Texture

The producers have been focused on the quilted texture of the cookies sheet in order to improve the airflow and achieve an even baking.

Features and Specifications

Color: Champagne
Material Type: Carbon
Product Dimensions : 18. 5 x 13 x 0. 5 inches
Item Weight: 3. 6 pounds

Price/ Value

The Art and Cook 3 Piece Non-Stick Carbon Steel Cookie Sheet Set can be found in the market with a really attractive and affordable price.

Decision Time

Our experts opinion on this matter is that if you are looking for a feasible cookies sheet that provides evenly baked food, the Art and Cook 3 Piece Non-Stick Carbon Steel Cookie Sheet Set is what you are looking for.
Pros
  • Multi-purpose baking sheet
  • Outstanding results
  • Quality product
Cons
  • None

9. Farberware Purecook Hybrid Baking Sheet

Read Reviews & Buy on
This Farberware 46331 Purecook Hybrid Ceramic Nonstick Bakeware Baking Sheet and Cookie Pan is a great solution for oven toasting, roasting, and baking. The Farberware(r) bakeware is made of ceramic nonstick features that provide a long lasting free of warp product. The product material can resist up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.
Expand to see more
PFOA-free and PTFE-free hybrid ceramic

The hybrid ceramic layer with non- stick properties, inside and outside the product, provides an outstanding food result. This specific layer assures easy cleanup as well.

Features and Specifications

Color: Lavender
Item Dimensions: 11. 25 x 17. 25 x 1 in
Material Type: Steel
Item Weight: 0. 8 ounces

Price/ Value

Considering the values and materials used in this set, the price it is being provided to the consumer is challenging compared to similar cookies sheets in the market.

Decision Time

In case you are looking for an easy to be cleaned cookie sheet that can produce excellent tasting foods, than this set is the appropriate and tailored solution to your needs.
Pros
  • Good quality
  • Easy to clean
  • Great non-stick action
Cons
  • It warps in the oven when the temperature is only 350 degrees

10. Wilton Candy Cooling Grid with Cookie Sheet

Read Reviews & Buy on
The Wilton 2105- 0170 Candy Cooking Grid with cookie sheet is a two in one solution for a delicious amount of cookies baked at home. Cookies coat will be smooth and properly brownish.

Expand to see more
Candy Cooling Grid

Once you cooked the cookies than you can cool them down using the Candy Cooling Grid provided in the Wilton 2105- 0170 Candy Cooking Grid set.

Features and Specifications

Item Dimensions: 11. 07 x 0. 87 x 16. 82 in
Pan measures: 15. 25 in. x 10. 25 in. x 0. 75 in.
Material Type: Steel
Item Weight: 1. 3 pounds

Price/ Value

The price it is being offered is considered as a generous one compared with other appliances in the market which offer similar benefits to this specific one.

Decision Time

It is considered to be a great cookies and candy sheet that can provide all kinds of cooking and still deliver same taste and accuracy.
Pros
  • It is a really attractive product
  • Delivers properly and evenly cooked cookies and candies
  • Quality material
Cons
  • The pan stains extremely easily

General considerations …

Whenever considering to buy a cookie sheet for the first time, or even add a new one to your existing collection, you need to know the purpose why you are buying it.

As our experts suggest, cookie sheets are being provided in the market in different types, material and shape. Some of them are best for lighter cookies, some others are best for darker ones. It is strongly advisable to buy tailored cookie sheets for any type of purpose. In order to understand the best choice, you need to have a look on the most frequent recipes you use.

Whenever choosing the best cookie sheet, keep in consideration temperature as well. Different type of cookie sheets stand different heat temperatures.

Our experts have been testing different types of cookie sheets, having in mind different type of users in regards to types of recipes and tastes. Thus, the proposed and reviewed best cookie sheets selected are coming as a proposition for all sorts of end users/ consumers. Each of you can find the appropriate solution for your demands amidst these 10 different types.