Sharp cheddar, roasted pimentos, and just the right amount of spice. This pimento cheese is on another level!
Grating the cheese by hand instead of using pre-shredded makes a huge difference in how creamy it turns out.
I always mix in a dash of smoked paprika because it deepens the flavor without overpowering the cheese.
A little softened cream cheese helps it hold together better and makes it spread more smoothly.
Once you taste this, you’ll never go back to store-bought!
How to Make Joanna Gaines Pimento Cheese
Ingredients
- 3 cups Mild White Cheddar Cheese (grated)
- 1 cup Sharp Cheddar Cheese (grated)
- 4 oz. Processed Cheese, such as Velveeta (grated)
- 2 cups Mayonnaise
- 1/2 cup Pimentos (drained and diced)
- 1/4 cup Green Onion (minced, light and dark parts)
- 1/4 cup Pecans (toasted and chopped, optional)
Step-by-Step Instructions
Step 1:
Start by grating the mild cheddar, sharp cheddar, and processed cheese into a large bowl.
Step 2:
Add the diced pimentos to the cheese mixture, ensuring even distribution for that tangy flavor.
Step 3:
Incorporate mayonnaise into the bowl gradually.
Stir thoroughly until smooth and creamy.
Step 4:
Sprinkle in the minced green onions and, if using, add the toasted pecans for a crunchy texture contrast.
Step 5:
Chill the mixture in the refrigerator for at least an hour before serving.
This will help the flavors marry and intensify.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Grating Velveeta Before It Is Firm Enough to Handle
Soft Velveeta smears across your grater and gums up the holes.
What I do is freeze the 4-ounce block for about 1 hour, just until it feels firm!
If shreds start clumping, return it to the freezer for 15 minutes.
Why Did My Finished Spread Turn Stiff Instead of Scoopable?
Mayo and cheddar firm up after chilling, so a cold spread tears crackers.
I’ll usually let mine sit out 15 to 20 minutes before serving.
Joanna Gaines keeps hers creamy with 2 full cups of mayo, so don’t skimp!
Why Does My Pimiento Cheese Taste Too Salty?
Sharp cheddar, Velveeta, and mayo all carry salt, so added seasoning tips it over.
I never salt before tasting the chilled spread.
To bring it back, fold in a handful of mild white cheddar!
Why Did My Finished Spread Lose Its Cheddar Texture?
Finely processed cheddar melts into the mayo and loses its shreds.
Joanna Gaines uses bagged grated cheddar, and I’ll always opt for it because thicker strands hold up!
If yours looks uniform, stir in a cup of coarse shreds.
Overmixing the Cheeses Until the Spread Becomes Pasty
Vigorous beating breaks down the Velveeta and makes the spread dense.
A shiny surface with no visible strands is your warning sign.
I stir gently with a spatula and stop once everything looks coated, and you’ll nail it!
Squeezing the Drained Pimientos Until They Lose Their Flavor
Pressing pimientos hard pushes out the sweet juice that balances sharp cheddar.
I’ve tested both ways, and I prefer a quick drain with a light paper-towel pat!
If it tastes bland, add a teaspoon of reserved liquid.
Folding in Toasted Pecans While They Are Still Warm
Warm pecans soften the nearby cheese and go soggy once chilled.
Cool them on a plate for 10 minutes, until cool to the touch.
That crunch is the Joanna Gaines finishing touch, and you’ve got this!
Pre-Shredded Cheese
Using pre-shredded cheese might seem like a simple shortcut, but it can affect the texture of your pimento cheese.
No bueno!
Pre-shredded cheese is often coated with anti-caking agents, which can hinder creaminess.
Optimize flavor and consistency by grating your own cheese.
Overdoing Mayonnaise
Adding too much mayonnaise can overwhelm the flavors of the cheese and pimientos.
You want to maintain a balanced taste where each ingredient shines.
Start with the recommended amount, and adjust slowly to suit your preference.
Tips and Tricks for Making This Recipe

Use Fresh Ingredients
Freshly grated cheese melts better and brings a richer flavor to the dish.
It’s tempting to use prepackaged grated cheese, but the results aren’t quite the same.
Adjusting the Creaminess
The amount of mayonnaise can be adjusted to get the perfect creaminess you prefer.
Less mayo for a thicker texture, or more for something indulgently smooth!
Spice It Up
If you’re a fan of spice, try adding a dash of hot sauce or a pinch of cayenne pepper.
This adds a slightly +zing to the mix for those who like it hot.
Pecan Alternatives
If you prefer not to use pecans, walnuts make a great substitute!
They lend a similar texture while adding a slightly different nutty taste.
What to Serve with Joanna Gaines Pimento Cheese Recipe
Classic White Bread
A classic choice for your pimento cheese is to spread it generously on some fresh white bread.
The soft texture of the bread complements the creamy cheese perfectly, and it brings nostalgia along with it.
Fresh Veggie Sticks
For a refreshing contrast, serve your pimento cheese with crunchy veggies like celery sticks, cucumber slices, or baby carrots.
Savory Biscuits
Pairing your pimento cheese with warm biscuits is another fantastic option.
The buttery, flaky layers of the biscuit provide a wonderful base that perfectly balances the rich flavors of the cheese.
Apple Slices
Here’s a unique twist—apple slices.
The natural sweetness and slight tartness of apples play wonderfully with the tangy cheese, creating an interesting and tasty combination.
Pretzel Chips
For something a bit different, pretzel chips offer a satisfying crunch with a hint of saltiness.
Their firm texture makes them perfect for scooping the pimento cheese.
Pickled Jalapeños
If you’re feeling adventurous, add some pickled jalapeños to the mix.
The tangy spice they bring to the table can give an exciting kick to each bite of pimento cheese.
Variations and Substitutions
Cheese Substitutions
You can experiment with different cheeses to suit your taste.
Try using Monterey Jack for a creamier texture or swap cheddar with extra-sharp cheddar for a bolder flavor.
Feel free to mix in some smoked gouda for a unique twist!
Adjusting Heat
To spice things up, you can add a few dashes of hot sauce or include chopped jalapeños.
For a milder version, leave out any spicy additions and use mild cheddar instead.
Creative Mix-Ins
Stir in some crispy bacon bits to add crunch and depth to your pimento cheese.
Chopped green onions incorporate a fresh, vibrant note that complements the rich flavors well.
Vegan Options
Use a vegan mayonnaise and try plant-based cheese alternatives to make this dish vegan-friendly.
Opt for vegan versions of your favorite cheeses to maintain the flavor profile.
Serving Suggestions
Get creative with serving!
Use your pimento cheese as a spread on burgers, or simply pair it with your favorite crackers or veggies for a nice snack.
How to Store Leftover Pimento Cheese
Make sure to place any leftover pimento cheese in an airtight container to keep it fresh.
This step helps to prevent it from taking on any unwanted odors from the refrigerator.
Refrigeration
Refrigerate the sealed container, and the cheese can last for up to 10 days!
Trust me, the flavors develop beautifully over time.
You can also choose to freeze any pimento cheese that you won’t consume in the immediate future.
Freezing
Use a freezer-safe container, and it will keep for up to three months.
Before serving it again, thaw the cheese in the refrigerator to maintain its texture and taste.
Stir it well after thawing, and it will be as delicious as the day you made it!

Joanna Gaines Pimento Cheese Recipe
Ingredients
- 3 cups Mild White Cheddar Cheese grated
- 1 cup Sharp Cheddar Cheese grated
- 4 oz. Processed Cheese such as Velveeta (grated)
- 2 cups Mayonnaise
- 1/2 cup Pimentos drained and diced
- 1/4 cup Green Onion minced, light and dark parts
- 1/4 cup Pecans toasted and chopped, optional
Instructions
- Start by grating the mild cheddar, sharp cheddar, and processed cheese into a large bowl.
- Add the diced pimentos to the cheese mixture, ensuring even distribution for that tangy flavor.
- Incorporate mayonnaise into the bowl gradually.
- Stir thoroughly until smooth and creamy.
- Sprinkle in the minced green onions and, if using, add the toasted pecans for a crunchy texture contrast.
- Chill the mixture in the refrigerator for at least an hour before serving.
- This will help the flavors marry and intensify.
